Jennifer Johnston, Registered Social Worker

Responding to Abuse Disclosures Within the Church: A Trauma-Informed Approach

Over the past several months, we have examined how Christian churches and institutions should deal with cases or allegations of abuse. In one newsletter, we detailed the legal duties that churches have to abuse victims; in another, we examined the legal liability that institutions can face when abuse allegations are brought to light.

The ugly reality is that abuse could happen in any church and any institution, and they need to be prepared with comprehensive abuse policies and a clear understanding of their responsibilities. But how should leadership respond when they are confronted with abuse allegations? How can they ensure that victims are properly cared for?

To address the most frequently asked questions, we spoke with Jennifer Johnston.

Jennifer Johnston, Registered Social Worker

Johnston is a Registered Social Worker and owner of Stillwaters Counselling, a private counselling practice in Peterborough, Ontario. Her professional background spans child protection, corrections, post-secondary education, and trauma-informed support for survivors of abuse. She has worked with Children’s Aid Societies, Victim Services, domestic violence shelters, and residential programs supporting survivors of human trafficking.

How can church leaders respond to victims in a way that is sensitive to the trauma they have experienced?

It is important that church leaders do not feel the need to determine the validity of a disclosure. Sharing an experience of abuse often requires tremendous courage and vulnerability. The response of the church should be rooted in compassion, taking the disclosure seriously, offering validation and support, connecting individuals with appropriate resources, and ensuring that proper documentation and reporting procedures are followed promptly.

It is equally important to recognize that survivors of trauma may present in a variety of ways. Responses can include fear, shame, sadness, minimization, shock, emotional detachment, or even deflection with humour, which can feel out of place. Trauma can also impact how memories are processed and recalled. Experiences are not always remembered or communicated in a neat, chronological sequence. A trauma-informed approach recognizes these complexities without interpreting someone's emotional presentation or difficulty recalling details as evidence that their disclosure is unreliable.

Church leaders must also resist the urge to conduct their own investigations. Asking leading questions, pressing for unnecessary details, or making assumptions can be detrimental to both the survivor and a subsequent investigation. Rather, leaders should focus on listening, documenting appropriately, ensuring immediate safety, and involving the relevant authorities when required.

Disclosure may occur immediately following an incident or weeks, months, and even years later. Within a church setting, internalized shame, fear of disrupting the institution, concern about the reputation of a respected leader, or the possibility of losing one's spiritual community can further complicate the decision to come forward.

Both research and my own professional experience have reinforced how profoundly the response to an initial disclosure can influence a survivor's healing. Churches have the potential to either compound the trauma or become an important part of the healing journey through the way they respond.

What are some things that leaders should do?

First and foremost, church leaders should respond to disclosures with compassion, openness, and a willingness to take allegations seriously, while resisting the urge to ask unnecessary questions or press for details that have not been volunteered. Their role is not to establish the facts themselves but to ensure that the individual feels heard, supported, and safe.

Helpful responses might include:

  • "Thank you for trusting me enough to share this."
  • "I'm sorry this happened to you."
  • "You deserve to feel safe."
  • "I believe you, and we are going to take what you've shared very seriously."
  • "This is not your fault."
  • "You don't need to navigate this alone."

Leaders should avoid making promises about confidentiality or investigative outcomes that they cannot guarantee.

Historically, there has sometimes been a tendency within churches to minimize allegations or attempt to manage these situations internally, perhaps out of fear of losing the community's trust, damaging the church's reputation, or creating division within the congregation. However, efforts to shield the institution from fallout can further harm survivors and ultimately undermine the very trust church leaders are trying to preserve.

Establishing safety must remain a priority. Where allegations involve a child, leaders must follow applicable child protection reporting requirements. In Ontario, this includes contacting a children's aid society when there are reasonable grounds to suspect that a child is in need of protection. Historical disclosures of childhood abuse also require careful consideration of whether children may currently be at risk. Police involvement and other reporting obligations should be addressed as appropriate to the circumstances.

Confidentiality should be carefully maintained, with information shared only as necessary for safeguarding, reporting, and investigation. This helps protect survivors from additional harm through congregational gossip, unwanted exposure, or ostracism.

When allegations involve someone in a position of spiritual authority, such as a pastor, elder, or ministry leader, particular sensitivity is required. The inherent power imbalance may make disclosure even more difficult. Survivors may fear the accused person's influence, the impact on the ministry, or the loss of relationships and community.

Christian communities must be especially careful not to confuse respect for spiritual authority with unquestioning loyalty. Transparency, integrity, and accountability are essential. Temporary restrictions or removal from ministry responsibilities may be necessary while an investigation is underway, both to protect those involved and to preserve the integrity of the process.

Where an adult discloses abuse and does not wish to involve police, leaders should respect their autonomy to the extent permitted by law, while assessing ongoing safety concerns and any applicable reporting obligations. Where an institutional investigation is appropriate, engaging an independent, qualified, and impartial professional can help protect against bias and preserve the integrity of the process.

Once immediate safety concerns, documentation, and necessary reporting have been addressed, connecting survivors with appropriate resources and ongoing support should remain a priority. Community organizations such as Victim Services, sexual assault centres, and specialized hospital programs can help individuals access social workers, therapists, sexual assault nurse examiners, and other supports.

An important consideration, particularly following sexual assault, is helping survivors understand their options without pressuring them to make immediate decisions. Specialized hospital programs can provide medical care, document injuries, and, when appropriate, collect forensic evidence. In some circumstances, evidence can be collected and stored without an immediate police report, allowing survivors additional time to consider their options. However, there are time-sensitive windows for evidence collection, and storage periods vary between programs. Again, this is where it is essential that churches reach out to the appropriate professionals to bring a full circle of access to care to victims and their families.

Church leaders do not need to be experts in these procedures, but they should know how to connect survivors promptly with professionals who can explain their options. Wherever possible, restoring a sense of choice, autonomy, and control is an important part of trauma-informed care.

What are some things that leaders should not do?

The absence of allegations is not necessarily an indicator of a healthy church. Rather, the health and integrity of a faith community are often revealed in how it responds when difficult allegations are brought forward. Church leaders should never prioritize institutional reputation, congregational comfort, or the standing of an influential individual over the safety and dignity of those reporting abuse.

Another particularly important consideration within Christian communities is the concept of forgiveness. Forgiveness can sometimes be misunderstood or even weaponized, particularly when it is presented as automatically requiring reconciliation.

Forgiveness and reconciliation are distinct concepts and must be treated as such.

While Christians are encouraged to forgive, forgiveness does not automatically require renewed trust, restored relationships, or continued access to the person who caused harm. Reconciliation, when appropriate and safe, requires accountability, meaningful change, and the rebuilding of trust. It cannot be demanded or rushed.

Pressure to forgive or reconcile prematurely can perpetuate shame, grief, betrayal, and further psychological harm. It can also create unsafe situations by placing survivors back into contact with those who have abused them.

It is not the role of church leaders to arrange or pressure survivors into face-to-face meetings, mediation, or confrontation with an alleged abuser in an attempt to resolve the situation. Abuse is not simply a relational disagreement; it involves violations of safety, trust, and often significant imbalances of power. Approaches designed for ordinary interpersonal conflict may therefore be inappropriate and potentially harmful.

Similarly, leaders should avoid using Scripture, prayer, or spiritual language to minimize the impact of abuse or encourage someone to move forward before they are ready. Spiritual support can be a meaningful part of healing, but it should never replace appropriate safeguarding, accountability, or professional trauma-informed care.

Throughout the investigation process, churches must remain intentional about protecting survivors from retaliation, unwanted contact, breaches of confidentiality, and further emotional or spiritual harm. Their safety and wellbeing should remain a priority long after the initial disclosure. Ultimately, establishing physical, emotional, and spiritual safety must remain paramount.

***

It is essential that institutions create abuse policies, safeguards, and awareness surrounding abuse and our legal and moral responsibilities. But knowing how to properly care for victims if a situation does arise is also essential, and we are grateful to Jennifer Johnston for sharing her expertise on this subject. We hope you also find it helpful. She can be reached at: Jennifer@stillwaters-counselling.ca

The Acacia Group accompanies faith-based communities as they navigate integrating their faith and fundamental beliefs in their works, while working within the religious freedoms’ provisions of the applicable human rights codes and Charter, and case law.

Acacia’s team members will assist you with institutional abuse response and third party investigations to ensure that it meets legal requirements and reflects your faith traditions.

This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, clinical, counselling, or other professional advice, and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice tailored to a particular situation. Reporting and safeguarding obligations are fact-specific and may vary by jurisdiction. Churches and other institutions responding to an allegation or disclosure of abuse should promptly consult qualified legal counsel and appropriate trauma-informed professionals.

Jonathon Van Maren is a strategic communications consultant with The Acacia Group, where he supports churches, charities, and faith-based organizations in navigating complex cultural and public issues with clarity and conviction. He is an experienced writer, speaker, and author with more than a decade of leadership in national advocacy, and his work has been widely published across leading North American and European outlets. Drawing on deep expertise in media engagement and crisis communications, he helps clients protect their mission, strengthen their public voice, and advance their work with integrity.


Sign Up for our newsletter